16 May 2008

How good is census indexing?

An email arrived from findmypast.com announcing their new transcription of the 1901 census records, starting with Gloucestershire and Somersetshire. The blurb read "The accuracy of our transcriptions, along with our high quality images, is what sets our censuses apart from our competitors'. After searching our transcriptions you may find people you haven't found on other sites."

I've also heard a respected genealogist (not an employee) at the Society of Genealogists make the claim that Findmypast's transcriptions are better than Ancestry's. How well does the claim stand up? I decided to rate them on a point basis, one point for each person correctly identified in a search for Reid in Somerset. Incidentally, Wikipedia states that Somersetshire is not the correct name for the county, but an archaic form that went out of fashion in the late 19th century.

A search on the exact name Reid yields 24 hits in Findmypast (FMP) and 22 on Ancestry (ANC). Of these 18 are identical. Whichever service you choose you stand a good chance of finding the person you seek. The glass is about 80% full. ANC and FMP each receive 18 points.

The first difference is a simple transcription problem. FMP finds Adam A Reid, ANC finds Adara A Reid. Looking at the original you can see how the Chinese indexers employed by Ancestry would read m as ra, but I'm surprised this was not caught in checking the work. One point to Findmypast.

The second difference is that FMP lists an Alex Reid living in Keynsham. However, looking at the original he, his wife and infant son are residing in Bitton, Gloucestershire. FMP has them in the wrong county. Penalize FMP three points for false identification.

ANC finds 14 year old Alvan Reid, a nephew in the home of Frances E Hancock. No amount of searching found this person on FMP, nor the Hancocks, nor several other people on the page. Unfortunately FMP has no way to search by piece, folio and page number as does ANC. Maybe there's a page missed. One point to Ancestry.

ANC finds Charles Tassela Reid and his wife Emily. FMP finds Charles Tassel Reed. Both are reasonable attempts at what investigation in other sources shows should be Charles Tassell-Reed. No points awarded.

FMP finds Martha Reid which ANC transcribes as Martha Rud. Rud is an unusual name and several of those found in the 1901 census look to be doubtful transcriptions. FMP appears correct; the entry is consistent with a marriage registered in late 1900. One point to FMP.

Finally FMP finds Reginold J Reid, ANC Reginald J Reid. On the original it certainly looks like --old, but which would you rather see it indexed under? Some argue you transcribe what you see, some that you normalize to a controlled vocabulary. In practice a worthwhile search engine should find the entry despite the difference in vowel. No points awarded.

Bottom line, 17 points to Findmypast, 19 points to Ancestry. Not a conclusive win, but also not a confirmation of Findmypast's claim. While the statement "after searching our transcriptions you may find people you haven't found on other sites" is true, it could equally apply in reverse.

One thing I did appreciate about FMP is the ability to zoom in the image more than you can with ANC. That may reflect a better quality image as FMP claims.

What the evaluation does show is the kind of variations to look for when an ancestor eludes you in the census.

15 May 2008

The DNA heritage test furore

In my posting comparing Ancestors and Ancestry magazines I made passing reference to Penny Law's article "Heritage Tests, revelation or rip-off?" in the June issue of Ancestors. Her conclusion, "its just a bit of fun." The article attracted the interest of the Daily Mail and the BBC. In a blog posting 14th May 2008: DNA furore Ancestors editor Simon Fowler admits that "My personal view is that DNA tests of these kind are a complete con and do not contribute to individual’s family trees."

Before painting such tests as a "complete con" surely the magazine should have made an effort to reconcile the results of the different tests? Was expert advice sought on the specifics of particular situation; if so it wasn't evident in the article. It appears that one test was done on the donor's autosomal DNA, so sampling across the whole spectrum of the donor's ancestors, whereas the other two looked specifically at the paternal and maternal lines, but with different terminologies used. Perhaps the fact that the article confirmed the editor's "personal view" was enough, along with the comfort of quoting the opinions of Cynics in the United States who may or may not be knowledgeable.

As to contributing to an individual's family tree, that isn't the aim of heritage tests. There are well established and highly successful DNA tests that are helping people sort out tangles in their family tree where paternity issues exist and helping link, or de-link, branches of family trees.

14 May 2008

Copyright

Hands up if you understand the rules, pros and cons around copyright as they bear on you as a creator and consumer of original material.

You don't see my hand up.

The little I do know comes from having listened to several presentations, and reading what I can, especially the weekly column written by Michael Geist published in the Ottawa Citizen and elsewhere. Read them, and much more, at his blog.

In his most recent column, on crown copyright, Geist asserts that "crown copyright costs Canadians hundreds of thousands of dollars while being used as a tool to suppress public criticism of government programs." Geist cites examples of use of crown copyright being denied for political reasons. In the most recent year for which records are available "crown copyright licensing generated less than $7,000 in revenue, yet the system cost over $200,000 to administer."

Copyright I may not understand, but a money losing proposition I do -- having been involved in my share.

Discussion on Canadian copyright legislation, with a new act expected to be introduced in the Commons soon, is one reason why it would be valuable to have a way for the Canadian genealogy community to speak in unison.

In the meantime, you may have noticed a new Creative Commons Licence logo is now found in the left hand column. You may freely republish for non-commercial purposes any material in this blog for which I own copyright. Commercial reproduction requires permission. Any reuse should acknowledge the source as Anglo-Celtic Connections, copyright John D Reid 2008, and include a link to the original where feasible.

13 May 2008

Ancestors and Ancestry

The latest issue of Ancestry magazine, published by The Generations Network Inc, arrived at my door on Friday. It's the May/June issue. I went to place it in the pile of other genealogy magazines, the top one of which was the June issue of Ancestors published by The (UK) National Archives and Wharncliffe Publishing Ltd, and then wondered how they compare.

Superficially they're similar, glossy and full colo(u)r. Ancestry is 8" by 10", with 66 pages plus the cover. The cover price is 4.95 US dollars. Ancestors is slightly larger, the A4 metric format. That's 210 by 297 mm , or 8-1/4" by 11-2/3". The issue has 74 pages plus the cover. The cover price is 3.50 UK pounds, 6.82 US dollars.

For the arithmetically inclined, Ancestors costs about 3.5% more on a per unit page area basis than Ancestry. I was surprised the difference is so small as UK prices are often much greater for comparable products. Part of the reason must be that while this issue of Ancestry has 12 pages of advertising Ancestors published 17 pages. Ancestry's ads are mostly full page spreads for products and services of The Generations Network. Ancestors has a wider variety of advertisers including may smaller ads for genealogy research services focused on a county or group of counties.

Feature Content
Both magazines have regular and feature content. Ancestry also has categories Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow with additional content as well as further categorizing the feature material. Of the four feature articles in Ancestry two "Getting Free Dirt on Their Hands" and "Shotgun Weddings" are US social history and of no direct interest to me. They were generally interesting; I probably wouldn't have taken the time to look at them if not for doing this posting. "Before My Very Eyes" reports on experience with two commercial photo-scanning and enhancement companies. Again these are US companies so of little direct interest. "Returning to Their Medicinal Roots" with its photos of food, comments on chicken soup and "an apple a day" stretched the bounds of what's suitable for a magazine titled Ancestry.

Ancestors has eight feature articles, two of them part of a DNA Special. Chris Pomery, author of two British books on DNA, provides a readable explanation of Genealogy of the Genes. Heritage Tests: Revelation of rip-off recounts writer Penny Law's experience with DNA tests by three companies for ancestral origins. Ancestry also had a DNA article in the Tomorrow section. You wouldn't need to be British to benefit from these. The remaining Ancestors features are mainly social history, some too specific to be of anything but general interest.

Regulars
Some of the regular Ancestry columnists had material of value to me. I enjoyed Colleen Fitzpatrick's analysis of an old photograph. It was annoying that the reproduction in the magazine was too small to allow you to deduce the same things she did. Megan Smolenyak's item in her Honoring Our Ancestors series was also instructive. The editors omitted identifying her as the author, except on the contents page.

In regular content Ancestors has a second good article, not specifically UK-oriented, by Chris Pomery, The Novelty of Networking. It also has book reviews and an Ask the Experts sections.

Overall
Despite the superficial similarity the magazines are different in that both are squarely targeted at their respective UK and US markets. It's unlikely I'd have seen this issue of Ancestry if it hadn't been included as a freebie with my Ancestry.com world subscription.

It wasn't until I read the masthead list of editors and contributers that I twigged to another difference. Women are just over one-third of names on the Ancestors list, nearly three-quarters for Ancestry. On visual appearance alone Ancestors, with maps, diagrams and images of old documents and steel-plate engravings would sit happily on the newsstand with the computer and technology magazines. Ancestry, with pictures of food and softer colours would not look out of place alongside homemaker magazines.

12 May 2008

The Ottawa Public Library needs a wake up call on digitization

Seven Northern New York counties, Ottawa's near neighbours with a total population under half a million, have cooperated to digitize and OCR more than a million pages of 31 local area newspapers and make them freely available online. Access them here. This was achieved through a library cooperative.

By contrast the Ottawa Public Library, serving a population approaching twice the size, appears MIA on digitization. When I asked one of their staff about this some weeks ago I was told the OPL was investigating digitization, then received an email stating "I was incorrect in thinking that we were undertaking a digitization project - we are not quite there yet."

"Not quite there" seems to be overstating the case. You can search the work plan for the Ottawa Public Library Board, scheduled for discussion on 12 May, for any mention of digitization. It's totally off the radar screen, not impressive for an organization that aspires to be "innovative."

I have sent an email to the City Councillors who sit on the Library Board, Jan Harder (Chair), Michel Bellemare, Peggy Feltmate, Diane Holmes, Shad Qadri and Marianne Wilkinson, requesting they add an item to the work plan that would see the OPL report to the Board on options for a local digitization project by the fourth quarter. Two responses so far have not been encouraging that the suggested action will be forthcoming, One Councillor does seem interested in exploring the issue further with the OPL.


11 May 2008

Digging Up Your Roots

Scenes from the Saturday 10 May event hosted by the Family History Center of the Ottawa Stake, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.






Hariette Fried from the City of Ottawa Archives who adds verve to any event.













Mike More, Chair of the Ottawa Branch of the Ontario Genealogical Society. The photo is cropped so as not to show the hordes on the other side of the table.

















British Isles Family History Society of Greater Ottawa featured information in their September conference.

















The Family History Center display was the only one with any need for a cash box.

10 May 2008

Irishmariners.ie

A website with an online index of Irish born merchant seamen (and one woman) contained in the CR10 series of index cards in the Southampton Civic Archives. The website currently contains information, including date of birth, on 11,345 Irish born merchant seamen active from late 1918 to the end of 1921 out of an estimated total of around 20,000 plus. You need to know both first and surname, or identity number, to search.

The Southamption Civic Archives holds 270,000 cards covering the the British Merchant Marine during the period from late 1918 to the end of 1921 which usually includes passport-type photographs. It is part of the Central Index Register of Merchant Seamen, a collection of over a million and a quarter merchant navy service record cards with details of people serving on board British registered ships between 1918 and 1941.

09 May 2008

Administrative changes

Unfortunately my attempts to change the address on this blog threw things off. When folks came to the blogspot address were redirected to a stale page at johnreid.ca. Sorry.

Waiting for the Vatican to drop the other shoe

According to the Catholic News Service the Vatican Congregation for Clergy has ordered dioceses across the globe not to give information in parish registers to members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

"The congregation requests that the conference notifies each diocesan bishop in order to ensure that such a detrimental practice is not permitted in his territory, due to the confidentiality of the faithful and so as not to cooperate with the erroneous practices of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints."

I confess not to be aware of this doctrine of "confidentiality of the faithful." It must have a particular meaning, but to the outsider sounds like the antithesis of proclaiming your faith.

Moreover, if collecting Catholic records in pursuit of LDS's "erroneous" rebaptism is so odious one would think it would also be objectionable for Catholics to have anything to do with records collected to such ends. Will the Vatican be issuing an edict prohibiting Catholics from using any LDS-collected genealogy records?

08 May 2008

Saturday May 10 Genealogy Events in Ottawa

At Library and Archives Canada (BIFHSGO ) 395 Wellington Street

9 am: Sylvie Tremblay speaks on effectively searching for ancestors and archival info at Library & Archives Canada (LAC)




10 am: Lucille Campey speaks on her new book "An Unstoppable Force: The Scottish Exodus to Canada."





At the Ottawa Stake Family History Centre 1017 Prince of Wales Drive

"Digging Up Your Roots" - 2008 Ottawa Ontario Stake Family History Fair
1 - 5 pm: Ten speakers, three different sessions run in most time periods.
See the full schedule on the Family History Centre website

06 May 2008

Report on "Who Do You Think You Are - Live"

I've been looking for a comprehensive report on the event this past weekend at London's Kensington Olympia. Blogger Chris Patten has it all here, including a link to a new user interface to The Times Online, free for "about two months."

Genealogy Society Membership Trends

Annual reports from various branches of the Ontario Genealogical Society have just appeared in Newsleaf. According to the President’s report membership in the Society is decreasing. Not every branch mentions membership trends, but its clear the situation isn’t uniform. Here are extracts from those that do:

Our membership has remained the same ... our membership dropped to 195, down from 222 the previous year … our membership has been stable for several years … we’ve experienced a slight decline in membership … membership this year dropped two persons … the slow, but nevertheless alarming slippage in membership numbers continues … branch membership has remained steady … for the first time in a number of years, our membership has been stable …. Membership remains about the same … with the decline in membership over the past few years … our membership is up … membership continued to decline in 2007, although in the 1.5% range which is an improvement over the previous few years … membership is down a bit from last year.

The President writes “I think that we are all aware of some of the main reasons for this decline.” I wonder if that’s true, or whether we just think we know. If even one branch is growing, and several are maintaining membership, what are the reasons they are bucking the trend?

05 May 2008

Citation Cheat Sheet

Sometimes even your friends won't tell you! I've blogged before about Alison Hare's presentation on Citations for Canadians, but didn't know her handout is now online at the website of the Ontario Chapter of the Association of Professional Genealogists. Scroll down to the link at the bottom of the page. I keep a hard copy handy, on the off-chance I might become inspired to cite a source!

Alison is on the program to present an expanded version, Citations for Genealogical Sources, at the BIFHSGO conference in September.

04 May 2008

Persistence pays

On Thursday the Genealogy Databases Posted or Updated Recently page for Ancestry.com showed a new database on US Army, Register of Enlistments, 1798-1914. As usual when I find a new database, but without great hope, I entered Northwood looking for my runaway great-great-grandfather. I found him!

He first enlisted in the US Army, about the last place I thought of looking, in New York. It was before the birth of his second child in England. He served in Texas, Kansas and Missouri where he died and was buried in a military cemetery.

Evidently he never contacted his family back in England. The opportunity to claim an inheritance if he put in an appearance didn't tempt him back, if he knew of it, and when his children married they stated he was deceased, even though he lived to 1896.

That find alone justified subscribing to Ancestry's World Edition.

03 May 2008

Start Writing Your Family History

Want to learn how to turn your family research into readable stories? The Ontario Chapter, Association of Professional Genealogists (OCAPG) announces "Writing A Narrative Family History," a day-long seminar with John Colletta, popular speaker, educator and author. Co-sponsored by the Canadiana Department of the North York Central Library, this is a day that will motivate and inspire your own family history writing: Saturday 27 September 2008 at the North York Central Library, 5120 Yonge Street, Toronto. Visit the OCAPG website at

http://www.rootsweb.com/~onapg

for full details of the day's schedule, how to register, information regarding book sales, directions to the event and nearby accommodations for out-of-towners.

A faculty member of the prestigious Institute of Genealogy and Historical Research (Samford University, Alabama) and Salt Lake Institute of Genealogy, John Colletta has planned the day around all the facets of good writing and good storytelling. One of John's own family accounts, Only A Few Bones, is a model for narrative writing but he is also known for They Came In Ships and Finding Italian Roots. Register early to ensure your space! http://www.rootsweb.com/~onapg.

via: Brenda Dougall Merriman

02 May 2008

Press releases of interest

Here are some announcements from FamilySearch coinciding with the UK "Who Do You Think You Are?" Show.

FamilySearch Teams with Findmypast.com to Increase Online Access to British Historical Records

Chelsea Pensioners and Militia Records, and Merchant Seamen Records, held at The (UK) National Archives will be scanned by FindMyPast, indexed and transcribed by FamilySearch. Presumably the index will be available freely, but following the link to the original images will cost.

New Genealogy Guides for England and Scotland

Finding Records of Your Ancestors, England and Finding Records of Your Ancestors, Scotland, are the latest additions to the popular series of free online publications. The guides are designed for those who have already gathered some family history information about their British or Scottish ancestors and are ready to search public and private records.

The British Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition

On May 13 the British Library, British Arts and Humanities Research Council, and cooperating institutions will launch the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (ncse). According to the British Library press release this is "a unique digital resource, which gives the user an informative, accessible and authentic experience of 19th century newspapers. The collection illustrates the phenomenal growth and transformation of the press in the 19th century and brings to life a society and century in flux.

The titles included in the ncse are:

  • Tomahawk: a satirical illustrated contemporary of Punch with elaborate, full-page cartoons
  • English Woman's Journal: an early women's magazine published and set by women
  • Northern Star: a social reformist newspaper, which gave away portraits of notable Chartists and at its height had nine editions on a single day
  • Publishers' Circular: a trade magazine from the publishing industry with lavish illustrations
  • Leader: a mid-century political weekly, which began by printing Town and Country editions
  • Monthly Repository: a long-lived theological and philosophical monthly."
I'm unsure how useful the collection will be for family history, but we'll soon find out as it's to be free online to all.

There's more information at: www.ncse.kcl.ac.uk, including links to some other interesting digitization projects under Resources in the left-hand column menu.

Via ResourceShelf

01 May 2008

A model for LAC accountability to users

February 26 saw the first LAC public consultation session which I summarized here and LAC summarized here.

Hours of operation were at the forefront, and we were informed that any change would not likely be instituted until June or July.

There were many other, smaller, issues raised. Increasing user satisfaction means addressing them, but its been two months now with no feedback. These issues should be handled close to the working level, assuming responsibility and authority have been pushed down the line as good management practice demands. Is ADM level involvement really required?

The model is for client responsiveness is TNA, The (UK) National Archives. Here's the meeting announcement for their latest monthly users forum.

Hear what’s happening at TNA and have your say, over lunch
You are invited to attend a meeting of the monthly TNA User Forum, which is open to all users of TNA services.

Lunch is available from 12:15, so the meeting can start at 12:30.

Agenda
Title: The National Archives’ User Forum

Date of Meeting: Thursday 17 April 2008

Time of Meeting: 12:15 for 12:30

Location: Training Room

1. Welcome - Jill Allbrooke, Head of Enquiry Services
2. Matters arising

3. (missing in the original)

4. Programme for improvements to TNA’s public services at Kew (Kew 2008) (standing item) -
Chris Cooper, Kew 2008 Programme Manager
5. Complaints, suggestions and compliments received by The National Archives - Paul Sturm, Quality Manager

6. TNA’s public service performance against our targets (standing item) - Jill Allbrooke

7. Open discussion
8. Next meeting: Thursday 15 May 2008, Talks Room


What I like about this approach is:

1. dealing with matters arising. Clients fear that management will treat meetings like a pressure release valve where users can let off steam, and then close the value again but leaving the heat on. TNA deal with at the next meeting, if they can't be dealt with sooner;
2. being open about complaints, suggestion and compliments raised by other means;
3. maintaining a regular monthly reporting on performance targets;
4. an agenda item for open discussion;
5. a commitment to regular monthly meetings;
6. copies of past meeting minutes and documents available online here.

Providing lunch is a nice touch, a tangible demonstration that the user input is appreciated and of value to the organization.

30 April 2008

More UK searchable genealogy & history websites - from Rick Roberts

Rick Roberts of Global Genealogy recently added a posting More UK Searchable Genealogy & History Websites to his Global Gazette. It includes seventeen searchable online databases with information including maps, military records, deaths, Wills, newspapers and more. Searches are free on all sites listed. Some charge a fee for accessing the supporting digital documents, others do not.

Rick is one of those people who helps make doing family history in Canada a pleasure. Visit Global's stand at a genealogy conference and you'll find him keen to listen, to understand your needs and recommend a solution.

Rick and Sandra have been bringing a wide range of books and materials to the marketplace of the BIFHSGO annual conference since the start. As is often the case he will be giving a pre-conference seminar, this year on the new version of Legacy Family Tree.

29 April 2008

Thanks to you, Cyndi and Randy

As of noon on Monday, 28 April this blog passed the monthly record for total hits, unique visitors and return visitors. Although I don't aim to break records it does indicate people find something of value in my ramblings. Thank you for visiting

Thanks also go to Cyndi Howells and cyndislist where I placed an announcement about the blog. It would be nice if Cyndi would include Anglo-Celtic Connections in her category Blogs for Genealogy. Pretty please.

Randy Seaver mentioned the posting on LAC recommended web sites in his most recent Best of the Genea-Blogs on his Genea-Musings site. Much appreciated Randy.

+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+


What we anticipate seldom occurs; what we least expected generally happens.
- Benjamin Disraeli